She shows up at the LA gym run by trainer Frankie Dunn (Eastwood), whose latest protégé . (Spoiler Alert: If you don't want to know the film's plot twist, stop reading now.). What does she have to live for now? if, as you say, all lives have value according to jewish law, than why not respect an individual's right to choose if and when to end one's own? PG-13 2 hr 12 min Dec 5th, 2004 Drama. Such was the life of Margaret (Maggie) Fitzgerald, known by her fans as "Mo Chuishle". She enlists the help of a reluctant trainer (Clint Eastwood) in this motivational movie. It gives fans the chance to cheer on the underdog and hate the villain at the . Ms. Anani, now one of the sport's stars, holds several championship belts in various weight classes from different sanctioning bodies. Maggie knows what she is up against given her tragic incident of spinal cord and body injuries from neck down. Also, after reading about the beautiful woman boxer not wanting to live , I don't even want to see the movie.On a personal note, I have a very handicapped young son, who taught me much about the worth of a life, and how beautiful of a soul a retarded little boy can have, and how much happiness he can bring . I've spent years visiting nursing homes and there are so many people there who are living full lives. People cheered her name and watched her in awe- she was wondrous and captivating. A bright red painting shows a hunched beast with jagged teeth hovering over a smaller, terrified figure. She still struggles to find words, growing increasingly frustrated and angry when she cannot. Scott Sigman, (23)
2. is living with another woman and has a baby with her. One of the finest films directed by Clint Eastwood, Million Dollar Baby packs a heavy punch largely due to Hillary Swank's turn as Maggie Fitzgerald, a waitress-turned-boxer. (52)
A fellow student watched as they pulled the plug from her brother-in-law following a tragic car accident; they were convinced by his doctors that this would be the most humane thing to do. 2 (2004) In the conclusion of the film, there was the surprisingly-calm and dignified death scene of Bill (David Carradine), brought on by Beatrix Kiddo/The Bride (Uma Thurman), his former lover and assassinatrix. As sad as this was, he was still able to enjoy a life of quality with family and friends, in spite of his limitiations and frequent pain. Thank goodness she had someone who loved her enough to spare her the further torment that surely would have been hers. Kathlyn G. Thayne, (40)
i admired the treatment and actions of both people involved! Finally, she began to speak, angrily, asking to see people long dead, like her mother. But I know that killing her is wrong. (25)
They are quick to add that they are not accusing Mr. Toole, who died in 2002, of stealing anything from Katie, merely suggesting that he used her life as the starting point. I suppose, though, I should not be surprised that Hollywood endorses it, as they seem to support anything that is the opposite of morality. He reluctantly agrees to mentor her, and she becomes a successful fighter. Anonymous,
He does not think the movie's ending will hurt, he said, as people understand that serious injuries in women's boxing are extremely rare and that regulation has become more rigorous in recent years. Found inside – Page 122And yes , a poor trailer - trash hopeful who wants to be a boxer gets caught up with these two losers . But the wannabe is 31 - year - old Maggie Fitzgerald ( Hilary Swank in a Golden Globe - winning performance ) , and she waits a year ... dasha18,
As agonizing as those days were, faced with the knowledge that I now have that I will never see my beloved mother in this life again, I would give anything to have those few moments and hear my mothers breath and hold her warm hand. She wanted to believe he cared about her more than the game. Hilary Swank knocked it out of the park as Maggie Fitzgerald, a woman who uses boxing to escape the world. Maggie wants to be a boxer even though she is in her 30's, which is an unusual age for beginner boxers. What is also not followed in the movie is that any patient in the United States in similar straits, may legally request to be removed from their vent, and be given a sedative to administer their own death. Would you rather she allow machines to keep her breathing and lose her body piece by piece - as she lost her leg because of the bed sores? For a brief period in the late 90's, the injuries that left Ms. Dallam near death were notorious in the boxing world. I also worry about a world where euthanasia is accepted, for it would likely lead to killing people who are merely inconvenient to keep alive. the difference between people searching G-d all time and people without any faith. Raymond,
This book is the result his four year study of the 23,000+ people (primarily Irish immigrants or their first generation descendants) buried from 1854 to 1920 at the Catholic Mount Auburn Cemetery (CMAC), Watertown, MA. He expended over 6 ... Maggie's decision to end her life is not a decision resulting from depression but from realistic contemplation. I forgot what. Her admitting form at the hospital in St. Joseph described her as comatose, responding only to "deep painful stimuli." 1. I went to the film Million Dollar Baby as an opponent of euthanasia but now I am not so sure. His prized welterweight boxer, Maggie Fitzgerald, was paralyzed and had become a quadriplegic, and could not breathe on her own. Maggie would be paralyzed for the rest of her life and on a breathing system. Jewish law would assert that all of the lives in question have intrinsic value. The woman in Florida who has been proven to be brain dead is one such case. I can understand the grief and desperation of Maggie. Clint Eastwood. Found insideBloodied but unbowed, he holds his own in the bout -- and lives to tell, in this timeless book on boxing and its devotees, among them Ali, Joe Frazier, Ernest Hemingway, and Norman Mailer. Shame on those who have so twisted technology to keep bodies alive and the soul trapped. I subscribe to autonomy (within the parameters of stable mental health) and self-deliverance in situations of intractable suffering. "When I saw that movie, I didn't know how it was going to end and when it did, I thought, wow. (Spoiler Alert: If you don't want to know the film's . By Amy LifeStar, (54)
In practice, it is more humane to end the horrific pain and suffering when reality dictates the path ahead.A loving God will understand our decisions to be sensible and help the one in intractable distress, even when we make mistakes. Her early floral watercolors have been replaced by what her sister calls monsters. Jasmin Furman,
The message is that disappointment over a shattered dream is a greater tragedy than death itself. Protect and heal as many fellow humans as possible. However, during this championship bout, she is viciously attacked from behind and sustains a career-ending spinal cord injury. Anonymous,
We moved her in with me that day.". If nothing better can be said for this movie it has caused us to evaluate our morals. The time we shared together was powerful: and I have heard from so many others how much they valued their time with him and how this had affected their lives profoundly. (49)
Frankie runs the Hit Pit boxing gym, and Scrap is his best friend and the maintenance man for the gym. Maggie's social role changes dramatically from a lean, fit, muscular boxer to a sickly, "terminally ill" patient. He was the sick one and yet he added so much to other people's lives. Markets Pro reporter. August 20, 2018 1:05 AM, A more recent example of life in spite of tragedy. While this movie may not show what we'd like to see as a Jewish view of the situation, it certainly does show a slice of life as it did and could easily happen anywhere in America. Shneidman, founder of the American Association of Suicidology, explained: "The paradigm is the man who cuts his throat and cried for help in the same breath.". Despite his handicaps, our son made a conscious decision to go full speed ahead with life, and to utilize every possible moment for doing mitzvot and spiritual growth. Anonymous,
Are we as a society 'championing' the 'right-to-die' cause because we do not want to aid the weak and disabled amongst us? March 12, 2005 12:00 AM. The 2004 movie Million Dollar Baby tracks the story of a female boxer Maggie Fitzgerald (Hilary Swank) who is mentored by a washed-up boxing trainer, Frankie Dunn (Clint Eastwood). pamza raihing,
Penelope Stowe,
He is 12 now and usually content (he is brain damaged). (47)
(6)
"I tend to be pretty hard on myself, when I can't remember things or I get lost. In my (VERY)personal opinion, this topic has in no small way, a great deal to do with the fact that people all over this world kill each other everyday in the name of personal beliefs or faith, and whats more... why we humans as a whole, continue to lay to waste this beautiful planet, and in turn annihilate our own species. Perhaps that is the real sin, not helping someone in such great need. I cheered the advice of the priest and when Eastwood was about to kill Maggie, I held out hope that he would stop at the end. an aging boxing trainer and the owner of a shabby gym; Maggie Fitzgerald (Hilary Swank), a 'white-trash' diner waitress who dreams of becoming a boxer; and Eddie Scrap-Iron Dupris (Morgan Freeman), a half blind ex-boxer who lives in Dunn's gym, cleaning and attending to it. Murray Gorelick,
Dennis Byrnes,
I mean that from the bottom of my heart. Hilary Swank (Million Dollar Baby, 2004) In the early scenes of Clint Eastwood's movie, Swank's Maggie Fitzgerald looks to be in danger of losing to the gym's heavy bag, but she eventually hones . it would be completely different if she had been paralyzed in any other way, but at the neck.... (53)
However, one day he simply said "I have had enough. (5)
Ye, what if there is something else to life? Million Dollar Baby (2004) - Hilary Swank famously packed on nineteen pounds of muscle training with bodybuilding champion Grant L. Roberts in order to believably play boxer Maggie Fitzgerald . My father and siblings were all there. They can print drivel and trivia, why don't they make deliberate room for that which can enrich the life of their readers? At the outset, he flatly refuses saying he has no interest in training a girl. Jane La Lone,
Found inside – Page 20... represented by Maggie Fitzgerald's climb to the top as a fighter . Even more important are the deepening bonds of love through which Frankie Dunn and Scrap essentially form a family with Maggie as they foster her talent as a boxer . Found inside2004: The Unborn Victims of Violence Act holds convicted murders liable for the deaths of both a pregnant woman and her ... Hilary Swank wins the Academy Award for Best Actress for her portrayal of Maggie Fitzgerald, a female boxer. How could G-d want this to go on? Let us analyze the issues raised by the movie: Why would someone ask to die and should we be willing to oblige? Who was born on Tuesday, 30 July, 1974 (Birthday), at Lincoln, NE and Hilary Swank's current age is 47 years, 1 month, 3 days (Updated Recently). The last years of his life were spent as a quadraplegic connected to a respirator. It often takes events like these for people to have a moment with which to reflect on life so that they could even "let go" and go January 2, 2016 11:55 AM, The ending was so sad I can't believe that Frankie enjected her with the lethal shot and disconnected her air way I could never do it even if they beg me, (57)
(34)
Just another hopeful opinion. (32)
Her competency has also shifted from a highly skilled fighter, a champion, a first-round knockout wonder, to one who is incapacitated and immobile, incapable of orchestrating even her own death without help. Maureen,
Stephanie Dallam, a nurse who has been her sister's prime companion and chief caregiver, said her family believed that F.X. He has taught a Jewish medical ethics class for the past 15 years. It is both a gift and a curse to keep a human alive as long as technologically possible. arnie,
We need to know what drives us in order to curtail our evil inclination, which we all have. Reminds me of the quote (often bandied about in various forms, in computer science circles) "The difference between theory and practice in practice is greater than the difference between theory in practice in theory. I still had hope and watched, disbelieving as she took her last breath. Later, she decided to save her medication and take it all at once. We take for granted a world where patient autonomy is the overriding ethical principle to which all other considerations must bend. Thank you for the life-affirming article. Then, realizing that was wrong, she scrunched her face in frustration. Dr. Eisenberg should be congratulated on a very inspirational article, and I look forward to reading his other works. First, the idea of beating someone to a bloody pulp for sport is offensive to me, and was the reason why I had not wanted to see it in the first place. Million Dollar Baby tells the inspirational story of Maggie Fitzgerald, a hard working, dedicated, and inspired rookie boxer who will do whatever it takes to be the best. Her vision was affected, leading to weird nighttime hallucinations that persist. Maggie in the movie has been reduced to a lifeless body attached to a head. Who then could help Maggie want to live? Hilary Swank was shot to death as Brandon Teena in "Boys Don't Cry" (1999). As a relative of someone who has had the plug pulled out from him, I can tell you that his death was anything BUT "clean, painless and quick. (26)
Of her soul. Throughout this difficult time, he still had hope for living and was an optimist. Maggie Fitzgerald, Million Dollar Baby Frankie ( Clint Eastwood ) is initially hesitant to train aspiring boxer Maggie Fitzgerald ( Hilary Swank ), but she eventually wears down his defenses and . I have a good friend who is a T6-7 parapelegic who truely has no wish for a cure. Without feeling useful, nobody wants to live so why prolong the agony. March 4, 2005 12:00 AM. Anonymous,
I see no purpose in this judgmental moralistic review of a movie portrayal. I kept saying "Don't do it. what inspiration would she be able to give? Maggie's fatal injury compelled her to take that decision; but there are millions who are mentally retarded, suffering from awesome diseases like cancer and AIDS. The writer of this article, in my guess, totally missed the point watching this movie. Exactly. ( and were asked to give permission for organ donations.!) I agree with jewish l I can only guess that his body had experienced enough trauma: he passed away quietly 2 days later, moments after Shabbat. ed menser,
Common wisdom declares that the wishes of a patient, whether they be for more treatment, less treatment, or physician-assisted suicide, must be respected and carried out. In 2004's Oscar-winning Million Dollar Baby, Hilary Swank plays Maggie Fitzgerald, a determined boxer who tracks down Frankie Dunn, an aging trainer played by Clint Eastwood.. March 2, 2005 12:00 AM. Later, the person's soul came to the doctor in a dream and told him that he (patient)had a few more days to complete and because of the doctor's actions, his soul can't rest. IN THIS CORNER, A REAL BOXER'S PAIN. THE AUTHOR RESPONDS: An up-and-coming Kansas City boxer named Sumya Anani -- known as Island Girl, because she had once lived in Jamaica -- needed an opponent for a fight in a fire hall in St. Joseph, Mo. (20)
Legacy.com enhances online obituaries with Guest Books, funeral home information, and florist links. Somewhere I read that the last survivors of Masada committed suicide rather than being captured, and I have read that this was condoned by Jewry. Thanks for the heads up, just because there are a million ads, it might not be worth two cents to someone who goes to a movie to be ENTERTAINED, not trained. While on life support, Maggie actually tries to take her own life by "biting the tongue", and when that doesn't work, she resorts to asking Frankie to end her life. However, the lady in question made a verbal agreement with her husband that they would not allow each other to die without dignity. In this too, we are only human and cannot be divine. Before his death, the Emperor chooses Maximus to be his heir over his own son, Commodus, and a power struggle leaves Maximus and his family condemned to death. No "win" is more valuable than a life. I am writing because I am feeling burned out and out of options about how to help my 29 year old daughter to guide her to discovering her way to working on what she's got going on. The movie tells the story of boxer Maggie Fitzgerald who, notwithstanding her gender and a late start in the sport, trains diligently and gets a chance at a title fight.
Islamic Prayer Guide For Beginners Pdf,
Do Electric Trains Cause Pollution,
Names Of Cleaning Products,
Walnut Variety Comparison,
Menards Vinyl Flooring Planks,
Ibm Security Verify Pricing,
Se7en Better Together,